
The human story is a contradiction within a contradiction We have traits that lead us forward into greatness and others that reveal our feet of clay. The story of humankind is glorious and horrendous at one and the same time. Even our most honored heroes are imperfrct and our villains have momentary flashes of conscience.
Life for each person is a challenge to do the right thing most of the time. We all know someone who appears to mostly choose goodness on a daily basis. We also know those who try the be the best version of themselves but falter over and over again. Then there are the souls who frighten us with their wanton attraction to evil. The eternal question of life is what makes one person seemingly good and another a horror? If only we had the ability to unlock the secret to that conundrum we might be able to mend souls the way we mend hearts.
There are so many ways of thinking about the morality of humankind. Are we born sinners who have to be somehow saved or do we become sinners over time in concert with our experiences. Is there such a thing as a brain that is damaged from birth or does society do the damage to a child who will ultimately become a criminal or a tyrant?
As an educator and a mother I have often grappled with such thoughts. I have wondered how much of my influence and those of others contribute to the formation of an individual. Is there a moment when we can guide young people into lives of integrity or is brokenness of spirit something so innate that it will take more than our meager attempts to reprogram a lost soul?
My experience has shown me that we become the persons that we are for millions and millions of reasons. We start with a genetic structure that determines much of the health of the many systems or our bodies. Our ancestors unknowingly contribute to how strong our hearts and bones will ultimately be. Our brains carry codes that influence how we interact with the word. Still we are not prisoners to a preconceived way of being. The influences of the entire collection of interactions with other humans has the power to change us for the better, turn us into monsters or break us.
All along our journeys through life we change, adjust, become just a bit different than we once were. Some of us have the confidence to adapt because of the love and security that surrounded us as children. Others struggle from neglect, want or cruelties inflicted on them.
How do we best deal with the broken souls among us without feeling helpless, inept, frightened? How can we find them and help them before their worst traits become firmly entrenched inside them? Is there a point at which we are able to help them or is there such a thing as someone who is hopeless?
I like to think that I did my motherly job in showing my daughters how to be the best versions of themselves. Nonetheless, I realize that mine was not the only influence on them. As they became adults and left my care they continued to develop in very independent ways, choosing ideas, relationships and ways of living that were different from my own. All I could give them that would last forever would be my love. I always knew that our thinking and our decisions would one day diverge. My hope was that they would always measure their own choices with a sense of morality. My relationships with my adult daughters is a now a healthy kinship between adults, no one of which is dominant. We are mostly of a mind but sometimes we agree to disagree.
I would like to think that I had a positive impact on each of my students as well. I tried to convey my love and concern for them but some were already so beaten down that I knew that my influence was nil. They were lost souls and I worried about them and what tragedies they might ultimately endure. I know that some of them ended up in prison. I was not as surprised as I was sorrowful. Somehow I had seen their downfalls coming but had no idea how to prevent them from being inevitable. There were too many more powerful and dangerous influences pushing them toward a tragic life for me to rescue them.
It would be wonderful to crack the code. To learn how to provide every baby that is ever born with the positive traits that make life more bearable and beautiful. Sadly we have yet to find the perfect formula for insuring that kind of security for everyone. Punishment may scare someone straight or it may destroy the spirit. The morality of religion may guide someone to be loving and kind or it may turn the individual into a self righteous hypocrite. Just the right combination of love, consequences, and moral instruction may help most of us to be good and productive people but too much indulgence or discipline or preaching can create a spoiled, angry and vindictive soul. Somehow we have to find a balance and therein lies the rub.



